- Home/
- Comparison/
- Self-Powered Crane/
- Krupp KMK5175 vs. Tadano ATF-650XL-2
Krupp KMK5175 vs. Tadano ATF-650XL-2
12 reasons to buy Krupp KMK5175:
Upper-stage engine
Full power | 104 kW and 90 kW | 13 % more or 14 kW |
Operation
Axels number | 5 and 4 | 20 % more or 1 |
Haul truck fuel volume | 378.5 l. and 299 l. | 21 % more or 79.5 l. |
Gear box
Maximum reverse gear | 14.5 km/h and 7.6 km/h | 48 % more or 6.9 km/h |
Carrying part engine
Full power | 370 kW and 260.2 kW | 30 % more or 109.8 kW |
Power measured at | 2100 rev / min and 1800 rev / min | 14 % more or 300 rev |
Maximum torque | 2020 Nm and 1730 Nm | 14 % more or 290 Nm |
Torque measured at | 2020 rev / min and 1080 rev / min | 47 % more or 940 rev |
Booms
Max. height at max. lifting angle without boom | 52.4 m and 40.2 m | 23 % more or 12.2 m |
Maximum angle of ascent | 85 degrees and 82 degrees | 4 % more or 3 degrees |
Maximum lifting capacity | 158757.3 kg and 58967 kg | 63 % more or 99790.3 kg |
Maximum working radius | 44.2 m and 36.6 m | 17 % more or 7.6 m |
9 reasons to buy Tadano ATF-650XL-2:
Upper-stage engine
Power measured at | 2300 rev / min and 1800 rev / min | 22 % more or 500 rev |
Sizes
Upperstructure rear swing radius | 3450.3 mm and 4953 mm | 30 % less or 1502.7 mm |
Operation
Upper structure fuel volume | 199.9 l. and 189.3 l. | 5 % more or 10.6 l. |
Gear box
Forward gears number | 12 and 5 | 58 % more or 7 |
Reverse gears number | 2 and 1 | 50 % more or 1 |
Maximum forward speed | 80 km/h and 69.4 km/h | 13 % more or 10.6 km/h |
Booms
Minimum height at maximum lifting angle | 10.4 m and 14.9 m | 30 % less or 4.5 m |
Minimum operating radius | 2.7 m and 3 m | 10 % less or 0.3 m |
Rotation speed | 2 rev / min and 1.5 rev / min | 25 % more or 0.5 rev |
Neutral reasons:
Upper-stage engine
Model | OM 366 A and OM 904 LA |
Manufacturer | Mercedes-Benz and Mercedes-Benz |
Sizes
Width with extended supports | 8177.8 mm and 6270 mm |
Transport width | 2996.2 mm and 2820 mm |
Hauler length | 13411.2 mm and 9986 mm |
Transport height | 3938 mm and 3650 mm |
Transport length | 15444.2 mm and 11780 mm |
Operation
Operating voltage | 24 V and 24 V |
Tyre size | 14.00R25 and 20.5R25 |
Working weight | 60101 kg and 53750.7 kg |
Gear box
Transmission type | Allison automatic CLBT 755 and ZF AS-Tronic 12AS2301 mechanical transmission |
Carrying part engine
Manufacturer | Mercedes-Benz and Mercedes-Benz |
Model | OM 442 LA and OM 501 LA |
Booms
Sections number | 5 and 5 |
Images
Sizes
1. Transport length | 15444.2 mm | 1. Transport length | 11780 mm |
2. Transport width | 2996.2 mm | 2. Transport width | 2820 mm |
3. Transport height | 3938 mm | 3. Transport height | 3650 mm |
6. Width with extended supports | 8177.8 mm | 6. Width with extended supports | 6270 mm |
7. Hauler length | 13411.2 mm | 7. Hauler length | 9986 mm |
8. Upperstructure rear swing radius | 4953 mm | 8. Upperstructure rear swing radius | 3450.3 mm |
Booms
11. Minimum operating radius | 3 m | 11. Minimum operating radius | 2.7 m |
12. Maximum working radius | 44.2 m | 12. Maximum working radius | 36.6 m |
13. Maximum angle of ascent | 85 degrees | 13. Maximum angle of ascent | 82 degrees |
9. Minimum height at maximum lifting angle | 14.9 m | 9. Minimum height at maximum lifting angle | 10.4 m |
10. Max. height at max. lifting angle without boom | 52.4 m | 10. Max. height at max. lifting angle without boom | 40.2 m |