- Home/
- Comparison/
- Crawler-Mounted Loader/
- Komatsu D31Q-17 vs. Komatsu D57S-1 Previous Pattern
Komatsu D31Q-17 vs. Komatsu D57S-1 Previous Pattern
4 reasons to buy Komatsu D31Q-17:
Sizes
| Width to outside of caterpillar track | 2250 mm and 2145 mm | 5 % more or 105 mm |
Operation
| Static tipping load | 4431.6 kg and 9421.1 kg | 53 % less or 4989.5 kg |
| Breakout force in folded state | 66.7 kN and 115.7 kN | 42 % less or 49.0 kN |
Carrier
| Specific ground pressure | 30.4 kPa and 74.5 kPa | 59 % less or 44.1 kPa |
7 reasons to buy Komatsu D57S-1 Previous Pattern:
Sizes
| Ground clearance at full height and unloading | 2890 mm and 2640 mm | 9 % more or 250 mm |
Operation
| Maximum speed | 9.5 km/h and 6.5 km/h | 32 % more or 3.0 km/h |
| Fuel Capacity | 260 l. and 115 l. | 56 % more or 145 l. |
| Cooling system fluid volume | 58 l. and 22 l. | 62 % more or 36 l. |
Motor
| Effective power | 100.7 kW and 49.2 kW | 51 % more or 51.5 kW |
| Displacement | 8.5 l. and 4.3 l. | 49 % more or 4.2 l. |
Carrier
| Rolling bearings number on either side | 6 and 5 | 17 % more or 1 |
Neutral reasons:
Sizes
| Length with bucket on ground level | 4045 mm and 5470 mm |
| Radius at high altitude unloading | 750 mm and 1190 mm |
Operation
| Working weight | 6998.9 kg and 14630 kg |
Motor
| Manufacturer | Komatsu and Komatsu |
| Model | 4D105-5 and S4D130-1A |
Carrier
| Track shoe width | 600 mm and 400 mm |
| Caterpillar track length on ground level | 1880 mm and 2425 mm |
| Track width | 1650 mm and 1700 mm |
Images
Sizes
| 1. Length with bucket on ground level | 4045 mm | 1. Length with bucket on ground level | 5470 mm |
| 2. Width to outside of caterpillar track | 2250 mm | 2. Width to outside of caterpillar track | 2145 mm |
| 7. Ground clearance at full height and unloading | 2640 mm | 7. Ground clearance at full height and unloading | 2890 mm |
| 8. Radius at high altitude unloading | 750 mm | 8. Radius at high altitude unloading | 1190 mm |
Carrier
| 9. Track width | 1650 mm | 9. Track width | 1700 mm |