Caterpillar 320D vs. Komatsu PC200-8

14 reasons to buy Caterpillar 320D:

Sizes

Clearance

450 mm and 440 mm

2 % more or 10 mm

Operation

Hydraulic system fluid volume	260 l. and 135 l.	48 % more or 125 l.
Engine oil volume	30 l. and 23.1 l.	23 % more or 6.9 l.
Boom reach drive mechanism fluid volume	8 l. and 6.6 l.	17 % more or 1.4 l.
Hydraulic pump flow rate	204.4 l/min and 439.1 l/min	53 % less or 234.7 l/min
Fuel Capacity	410 l. and 400 l.	2 % more or 10 l.
Cooling system fluid volume	25 l. and 20.4 l.	18 % more or 4.6 l.

Booms/sections features 2

Maximum excavation depth	6720 mm and 6620 mm	1 % more or 100 mm
Maximum radius along ground level	9860 mm and 9700 mm	2 % more or 160 mm
Maximum vertical wall digging depth	6060 mm and 5980 mm	1 % more or 80 mm

Booms/sections features 1

Maximum radius along ground level	10760 mm and 9190 mm	15 % more or 1570 mm
Maximum loading height	6940 mm and 6890 mm	1 % more or 50 mm
Maximum excavation depth	7660 mm and 6095 mm	20 % more or 1565 mm
Maximum vertical wall digging depth	6970 mm and 5430 mm	22 % more or 1540 mm

10 reasons to buy Komatsu PC200-8:

Swing device

Rotation speed	12.4 rev / min and 11.5 rev / min	7 % more or 0.9 rev
Swing torque	49907 lb / ft and 45612 lb / ft	9 % more or 4295 lb

Sizes

Counterweight ground clearance	1085 mm and 1020 mm	6 % more or 65 mm
Width to outside of caterpillar track	3000 mm and 2800 mm	7 % more or 200 mm

Operation

Hydraulic system overflow valve pressure

37231.7 kPa and 34997.8 kPa

6 % more or 2233.9 kPa

Motor

Effective power	110 kW and 104.4 kW	5 % more or 5.6 kW
Power measured at	2000 rev / min and 1800 rev / min	10 % more or 200 rev
Displacement	6.7 l. and 6.4 l.	4 % more or 0.3 l.

Carrier

Hook traction force

178 kN and 206 kN

14 % less or 28 kN

Booms/sections features 2

Maximum loading height

7110 mm and 6940 mm

2 % more or 170 mm

Neutral reasons:

Sizes

Height to cab upper part	2950 mm and 3040 mm
Rear platform swing radius	2750 mm and 2750 mm
Caterpillar track length on ground level	3265 mm and 3275 mm

Shovel

Maximum bucket volume

1.2 m3 and 1.2 m3

Operation

Working weight

20330 kg and 20010 kg

Motor

Manufacturer	Caterpillar and Komatsu
Model	3066 ATAAC and SAA6D107E-1
Aspiration	turbocharging and turbocharging and cooling at the outlet

Carrier

Shoe dimensions	600 mm and 800 mm
Maximum travel speed	5.5 km/h and 5.5 km/h
Track width	2200 mm and 2200 mm

Booms/sections features 2

Unit load-transfer height	3030 mm and 3040 mm
Unit load-transfer length	9460 mm and 4815 mm
Maximum cut height	9490 mm and 10000 mm

Booms/sections features 1

Maximum cut height	9940 mm and 9800 mm
Unit load-transfer height	3740 mm and 3190 mm
Unit load-transfer length	9440 mm and 5700 mm

Images

Sizes

8. Rear platform swing radius	2750 mm	8. Rear platform swing radius	2750 mm
15. Counterweight ground clearance	1020 mm	15. Counterweight ground clearance	1085 mm
2. Width to outside of caterpillar track	2800 mm	2. Width to outside of caterpillar track	3000 mm
4. Caterpillar track length on ground level	3265 mm	4. Caterpillar track length on ground level	3275 mm
5. Clearance	450 mm	5. Clearance	440 mm
7. Height to cab upper part	2950 mm	7. Height to cab upper part	3040 mm

Carrier

6. Track width	2200 mm	6. Track width	2200 mm
14. Shoe dimensions	600 mm	14. Shoe dimensions	800 mm

Booms/sections features 1

13. Maximum excavation depth	6720 mm	13. Maximum excavation depth	6620 mm
1. Unit load-transfer length	9460 mm	1. Unit load-transfer length	4815 mm
3. Unit load-transfer height	3050 mm	3. Unit load-transfer height	3040 mm
9. Maximum cut height	9290 mm	9. Maximum cut height	10000 mm
10. Maximum loading height	6290 mm	10. Maximum loading height	7110 mm
11. Maximum radius along ground level	9460 mm	11. Maximum radius along ground level	9700 mm
12. Maximum vertical wall digging depth	5650 mm	12. Maximum vertical wall digging depth	5980 mm