- Home/
- Comparison/
- Hydraulic Shovel/
- Komatsu PC228US-3 vs. Volvo EC700CL
Komatsu PC228US-3 vs. Volvo EC700CL
9 reasons to buy Komatsu PC228US-3:
Swing device
Rotation speed | 11 rev / min and 6.7 rev / min | 39 % more or 4.3 rev |
Operation
Hydraulic system overflow valve pressure | 38000 kPa and 34335.9 kPa | 10 % more or 3664.1 kPa |
Hydraulic pump flow rate | 428 l/min and 870.6 l/min | 51 % less or 442.6 l/min |
Motor
Power measured at | 1950 rev / min and 1800 rev / min | 8 % more or 150 rev |
Carrier
Specific ground pressure | 51 kPa and 75.2 kPa | 32 % less or 24.2 kPa |
Maximum travel speed | 5.5 km/h and 4.6 km/h | 16 % more or 0.9 km/h |
Hook traction force | 202 kN and 453 kN | 55 % less or 251 kN |
Booms/sections features 1
Maximum loading height | 7825 mm and 6960 mm | 11 % more or 865 mm |
Maximum vertical wall digging depth | 5980 mm and 5065 mm | 15 % more or 915 mm |
15 reasons to buy Volvo EC700CL:
Sizes
Clearance | 858 mm and 440 mm | 49 % more or 418 mm |
Counterweight ground clearance | 1507 mm and 1060 mm | 30 % more or 447 mm |
Width to outside of caterpillar track | 4286 mm and 2800 mm | 35 % more or 1486 mm |
Operation
Fuel Capacity | 840 l. and 320 l. | 62 % more or 520 l. |
Cooling system fluid volume | 65 l. and 22.4 l. | 66 % more or 42.6 l. |
Hydraulic system fluid volume | 655 l. and 126 l. | 81 % more or 529 l. |
Engine oil volume | 52 l. and 24 l. | 54 % more or 28 l. |
Boom reach drive mechanism fluid volume | 12 l. and 6.6 l. | 45 % more or 5.4 l. |
Motor
Full power | 346 kW and 107 kW | 69 % more or 239 kW |
Displacement | 16.1 l. and 5.9 l. | 63 % more or 10.2 l. |
Carrier
Support rollers number on either side | 3 and 2 | 33 % more or 1 |
Rolling bearings number on either side | 8 and 7 | 12 % more or 1 |
Track shoes number per side | 48 and 45 | 6 % more or 3 |
Booms/sections features 1
Maximum radius along ground level | 11200 mm and 9700 mm | 13 % more or 1500 mm |
Maximum excavation depth | 7250 mm and 6620 mm | 9 % more or 630 mm |
Neutral reasons:
Sizes
Rear platform swing radius | 1680 mm and 4090 mm |
Caterpillar track length on ground level | 3270 mm and 4750 mm |
Height to cab upper part | 3010 mm and 3520 mm |
Operation
Working weight | 21980 kg and 71699.3 kg |
Motor
Aspiration | Turbocharging with subsequent air cooling (by a cooling radiator) and Turbocharging with intercooler |
Cylinders number | 6 and 6 |
Manufacturer | Komatsu and Volvo |
Model | SAA6D102E and D16E EAE3 |
Carrier
Track width | 2200 mm and 3350 mm |
Shoe dimensions | 600 mm and 900 mm |
Booms/sections features 1
Maximum cut height | 10700 mm and 10980 mm |
Unit load-transfer height | 3010 mm and 4855 mm |
Unit load-transfer length | 8700 mm and 12200 mm |
Images
Sizes
2. Width to outside of caterpillar track | 2800 mm | 2. Width to outside of caterpillar track | 4286 mm |
4. Caterpillar track length on ground level | 3270 mm | 4. Caterpillar track length on ground level | 4750 mm |
5. Clearance | 440 mm | 5. Clearance | 858 mm |
7. Height to cab upper part | 3010 mm | 7. Height to cab upper part | 3520 mm |
8. Rear platform swing radius | 1680 mm | 8. Rear platform swing radius | 4090 mm |
15. Counterweight ground clearance | 1060 mm | 15. Counterweight ground clearance | 1507 mm |
Carrier
6. Track width | 2200 mm | 6. Track width | 3350 mm |
14. Shoe dimensions | 600 mm | 14. Shoe dimensions | 900 mm |
Booms/sections features 1
10. Maximum loading height | 7825 mm | 10. Maximum loading height | 6960 mm |
11. Maximum radius along ground level | 9700 mm | 11. Maximum radius along ground level | 11200 mm |
12. Maximum vertical wall digging depth | 5980 mm | 12. Maximum vertical wall digging depth | 5065 mm |
13. Maximum excavation depth | 6620 mm | 13. Maximum excavation depth | 7250 mm |
1. Unit load-transfer length | 8700 mm | 1. Unit load-transfer length | 13320 mm |
3. Unit load-transfer height | 3010 mm | 3. Unit load-transfer height | 4660 mm |
9. Maximum cut height | 10700 mm | 9. Maximum cut height | 12490 mm |