Caterpillar IT28G vs. John Deere TC54H

15 reasons to buy Caterpillar IT28G:

Sizes

Unloading ground clearance at maximum lifting	2911 mm and 2846 mm	2 % more or 65 mm
Maximum lifting height	3843 mm and 3747 mm	2 % more or 96 mm
Hook height at maximum lifting in unfolded state	7185 mm and 6983 mm	3 % more or 202 mm

Shovel

Breakout power

104.3 kN and 10345 kN

99 % less or 10240.7 kN

Operation

Generator current strength	80 amperes and 55 amperes	31 % more or 25 amperes
Cooling system fluid volume	42 l. and 23 l.	45 % more or 19 l.
Transmission fluid volume	34.5 l. and 20 l.	42 % more or 14.5 l.
Front differential fluid volume	26 l. and 19 l.	27 % more or 7 l.
Rear differential fluid volume	25 l. and 19 l.	24 % more or 6 l.
Hydraulic system fluid volume	125 l. and 106 l.	15 % more or 19 l.

Motor

Full power	116.3 kW and 103 kW	11 % more or 13.3 kW
Effective power	108.1 kW and 97 kW	10 % more or 11.1 kW
Power measured at	2300 rev / min and 2200 rev / min	4 % more or 100 rev

Hydraulic system

Unloading time

1.4 sec and 1.5 sec

7 % less or 0.1 sec

Gear box

Maximum reverse gear

26 km/h and 25 km/h

4 % more or 1 km/h

16 reasons to buy John Deere TC54H:

Sizes

Radius at maximum height and unloading	1298 mm and 1014 mm	22 % more or 284 mm
Fork tines length	1220 mm and 1200 mm	2 % more or 20 mm
Clearance	424 mm and 407 mm	4 % more or 17 mm
Hook height at maximum lifting in folded state	5667 mm and 5578 mm	2 % more or 89 mm
Hook radius at maximum lifting in folded state	2302 mm and 1608 mm	30 % more or 694 mm
Hook radius at maximum lifting in unfolded state	3663 mm and 2791 mm	24 % more or 872 mm

Shovel

Brimmed bucket capacity

2 m3 and 1.7 m3

15 % more or 0.3 m3

Operation

Manipulator static tipping load	4046 kg and 5355 kg	24 % less or 1309 kg
Static bucket tipping load	8004 kg and 9034 kg	11 % less or 1030 kg
Fuel Capacity	246.1 l. and 225 l.	9 % more or 21.1 l.
Engine oil volume	18 l. and 16 l.	11 % more or 2 l.
Turn radius	4959 mm and 5070 mm	2 % less or 111 mm

Motor

Displacement

6.8 l. and 6 l.

12 % more or 0.8 l.

Hydraulic system

Pump bandwidth	155.2 l/min and 104 l/min	33 % more or 51.2 l/min
Lifting time	5.8 sec and 6.1 sec	5 % less or 0.3 sec

Gear box

Maximum forward speed

40 km/h and 38 km/h

5 % more or 2 km/h

Neutral reasons:

Sizes

Length with bucket on ground level	7318 mm and 7365 mm
Height to cab upper part	3268 mm and 3230 mm
Wheelbase	2900 mm and 2900 mm
Length with forks on ground level	7557 mm and 7585 mm

Operation

Operating voltage	24 V and 24 V
Tyre size	20.5R25 L3 XHA and 17.5-25
Working weight	12640 kg and 12043.8 kg

Motor

Model

3116T and 6068T

Hydraulic system

Overflow valve pressure	20700 kPa and 24850 kPa
Lowering time	2.8 sec and 2.8 sec

Gear box

Forward gears number	4 and 4
Reverse gears number	3 and 3

Images

Sizes

12. Hook height at maximum lifting in folded state	5578 mm	12. Hook height at maximum lifting in folded state	5667 mm
13. Hook height at maximum lifting in unfolded state	7185 mm	13. Hook height at maximum lifting in unfolded state	6983 mm
14. Hook radius at maximum lifting in folded state	1608 mm	14. Hook radius at maximum lifting in folded state	2302 mm
15. Hook radius at maximum lifting in unfolded state	2791 mm	15. Hook radius at maximum lifting in unfolded state	3663 mm
1. Length with bucket on ground level	7318 mm	1. Length with bucket on ground level	7365 mm
3. Height to cab upper part	3268 mm	3. Height to cab upper part	3230 mm
4. Wheelbase	2900 mm	4. Wheelbase	2900 mm
5. Clearance	407 mm	5. Clearance	424 mm
7. Unloading ground clearance at maximum lifting	2911 mm	7. Unloading ground clearance at maximum lifting	2846 mm
9. Fork tines length	1200 mm	9. Fork tines length	1220 mm
10. Length with forks on ground level	7557 mm	10. Length with forks on ground level	7585 mm
11. Maximum lifting height	3843 mm	11. Maximum lifting height	3747 mm