- Home/
- Comparison/
- Attached Equipment/
- Komatsu WA200PT-5 vs. Caterpillar IT38G
Komatsu WA200PT-5 vs. Caterpillar IT38G
13 reasons to buy Komatsu WA200PT-5:
Sizes
Hook height at maximum lifting in unfolded state | 7339 mm and 6713 mm | 9 % more or 626 mm |
Hook radius at maximum lifting in folded state | 2671 mm and 2451 mm | 8 % more or 220 mm |
Unloading ground clearance at maximum lifting | 2745 mm and 2698 mm | 2 % more or 47 mm |
Clearance | 495 mm and 399 mm | 19 % more or 96 mm |
Maximum lifting height | 3708 mm and 3591 mm | 3 % more or 117 mm |
Hook height at maximum lifting in folded state | 6751 mm and 5590 mm | 17 % more or 1161 mm |
Shovel
Breakout power | 109 kN and 127 kN | 14 % less or 18 kN |
Operation
Static bucket tipping load | 7644 kg and 10211 kg | 25 % less or 2567 kg |
Static tipping forks load | 5902 kg and 8302 kg | 29 % less or 2400 kg |
Manipulator static tipping load | 3092 kg and 5504 kg | 44 % less or 2412 kg |
Turn radius | 4950 mm and 6114 mm | 19 % less or 1164 mm |
Gear box
Reverse gears number | 4 and 3 | 25 % more or 1 |
Maximum reverse gear | 38 km/h and 23.3 km/h | 39 % more or 14.7 km/h |
16 reasons to buy Caterpillar IT38G:
Sizes
Hook radius at maximum lifting in unfolded state | 3591 mm and 3156 mm | 12 % more or 435 mm |
Radius at maximum height and unloading | 1259 mm and 1066.8 mm | 15 % more or 192.2 mm |
Shovel
Brimmed bucket capacity | 1.8 m3 and 1.6 m3 | 11 % more or 0.2 m3 |
Operation
Generator current strength | 80 amperes and 60 amperes | 25 % more or 20 amperes |
Fuel Capacity | 257 l. and 184 l. | 28 % more or 73 l. |
Cooling system fluid volume | 43 l. and 17.5 l. | 59 % more or 25.5 l. |
Engine oil volume | 30 l. and 19.5 l. | 35 % more or 10.5 l. |
Front differential fluid volume | 24 l. and 18 l. | 25 % more or 6 l. |
Rear differential fluid volume | 27 l. and 18 l. | 33 % more or 9 l. |
Hydraulic system fluid volume | 76 l. and 67 l. | 12 % more or 9 l. |
Motor
Full power | 134 kW and 95 kW | 29 % more or 39 kW |
Effective power | 119 kW and 89 kW | 25 % more or 30 kW |
Displacement | 7.2 l. and 6 l. | 17 % more or 1.2 l. |
Hydraulic system
Lowering time | 2.9 sec and 3.6 sec | 19 % less or 0.7 sec |
Lifting time | 5.8 sec and 5.9 sec | 2 % less or 0.1 sec |
Gear box
Maximum forward speed | 38.8 km/h and 38 km/h | 2 % more or 0.8 km/h |
Neutral reasons:
Sizes
Length with bucket on ground level | 7305 mm and 7631 mm |
Between tyres width | 2492 mm and 2601 mm |
Height to cab upper part | 3180 mm and 3330 mm |
Wheelbase | 2840 mm and 3020 mm |
Length with forks on ground level | 7661 mm and 7935 mm |
Operation
Operating voltage | 24 V and 24 V |
Rear axle oscillating | 24 degrees and 12 degrees |
Tyre size | 20.5/25-12PR (L2) and 20.5R25 |
Working weight | 10329 kg and 14583 kg |
Motor
Manufacturer | Komatsu and Caterpillar |
Model | SAA6D102E-2 and 3126B ATAAC |
Hydraulic system
Unloading time | 2 sec and 2 sec |
Type of pump | gear type pump and Piston |
Overflow valve pressure | 19900 kPa and 24800 kPa |
Gear box
Transmission type | Hydrostatic, 1 pump, 2 electric motors with the speed range selection and powershift transmission |
Forward gears number | 4 and 4 |
Images
Sizes
1. Length with bucket on ground level | 7305 mm | 1. Length with bucket on ground level | 7631 mm |
2. Between tyres width | 2492 mm | 2. Between tyres width | 2601 mm |
3. Height to cab upper part | 3180 mm | 3. Height to cab upper part | 3330 mm |
4. Wheelbase | 2840 mm | 4. Wheelbase | 3020 mm |
5. Clearance | 495 mm | 5. Clearance | 399 mm |
7. Unloading ground clearance at maximum lifting | 2745 mm | 7. Unloading ground clearance at maximum lifting | 2698 mm |
10. Length with forks on ground level | 7661 mm | 10. Length with forks on ground level | 7935 mm |
11. Maximum lifting height | 3708 mm | 11. Maximum lifting height | 3591 mm |
12. Hook height at maximum lifting in folded state | 6751 mm | 12. Hook height at maximum lifting in folded state | 5590 mm |
13. Hook height at maximum lifting in unfolded state | 7339 mm | 13. Hook height at maximum lifting in unfolded state | 6713 mm |
14. Hook radius at maximum lifting in folded state | 2671 mm | 14. Hook radius at maximum lifting in folded state | 2451 mm |
15. Hook radius at maximum lifting in unfolded state | 3156 mm | 15. Hook radius at maximum lifting in unfolded state | 3591 mm |