vs.

      Caterpillar 446 vs. John Deere 310J

      18 reasons to buy Caterpillar 446:

      Sizes

      Clearance 332 mm and 305 mm 8 % more or 27 mm

      Operation

      Front axle fluid volume 9.3 l. and 6.5 l. 30 % more or 2.8 l.
      Rear axle fluid volume 31 l. and 18 l. 42 % more or 13 l.
      Hydraulic system fluid volume 154 l. and 91 l. 41 % more or 63 l.
      Cooling system fluid volume 30 l. and 21 l. 30 % more or 9 l.
      Transmission fluid volume 26 l. and 15 l. 42 % more or 11 l.

      Motor

      Effective power 70.8 kW and 54 kW 24 % more or 16.8 kW
      Power measured at 2200 rev / min and 2000 rev / min 9 % more or 200 rev

      Load-transfer device

      Lifting capacity at full height 3710 kg and 2815 kg 24 % more or 895 kg
      Ground clearance at maximum unloading height 2699 mm and 2690 mm 0 % more or 9 mm
      Radius at max unloading height 868 mm and 785 mm 10 % more or 83 mm
      Digging depth 162 mm and 160 mm 1 % more or 2 mm

      Hydraulic system

      Pump bandwidth 162 l/min and 106 l/min 35 % more or 56 l/min

      Gear box

      Maximum reverse gear 36.5 km/h and 13.2 km/h 64 % more or 23.3 km/h

      Backdigger

      Loading height in folded state 4310 mm and 3330 mm 23 % more or 980 mm
      Loading height in unfolded state 4894 mm and 4240 mm 13 % more or 654 mm
      Digging depth in folded state 5219 mm and 4340 mm 17 % more or 879 mm
      Digging depth in unfolded state 6528 mm and 5460 mm 16 % more or 1068 mm

      8 reasons to buy John Deere 310J:

      Operation

      Generator current strength 90 amperes and 55 amperes 39 % more or 35 amperes
      Fuel Capacity 155 l. and 125 l. 19 % more or 30 l.
      Oil system fluid volume 13 l. and 11 l. 15 % more or 2 l.

      Motor

      Displacement 4.5 l. and 4.4 l. 2 % more or 0.1 l.

      Load-transfer device

      Bucket breakout force 37.8 kN and 53.4 kN 29 % less or 15.6 kN

      Gear box

      Maximum forward speed 36.1 km/h and 33 km/h 9 % more or 3.1 km/h

      Backdigger

      Load at maximum lifting in folded state 1154 kg and 2237 kg 48 % less or 1083 kg
      Load at maximum lifting in unfolded state 1010 kg and 1030 kg 2 % less or 20 kg

      Neutral reasons:

      Sizes

      Wheelbase 2233 mm and 2110 mm
      Transport length 7954 mm and 7086.6 mm
      Transport width 2432 mm and 2180 mm
      Transport height 4193 mm and 3430 mm
      Height to cab upper part 2864 mm and 2743.2 mm

      Operation

      Front tyres size 2wd / 4wd 14.5/75-16.1 10PR / 12.5-20 10PR and 11L-15 SL F-3(8)(12)/12-16.5 NHS SS-1(8)
      Rear tyres size 2wd/4wd 21L-24 12PR / 21L-24 12PR and 19.5L-24 R-4(10)
      Operating voltage 12 V and 12 V
      Working weight 2wd 8892 kg and 6260 kg
      Working weight 4wd 9088 kg and 7321 kg

      Motor

      Model 3114 and 4045D
      Cylinders number 4 and 4
      Aspiration turbocharging and natural aspiration
      Manufacturer Caterpillar and John Deere

      Load-transfer device

      Shovel width 2432 mm and 2184.4 mm

      Hydraulic system

      Type of pump Variable flow and gear type pump
      Overflow valve pressure 19994.8 kPa and 24993.5 kPa

      Gear box

      Transmission type powershift transmission and powershift transmission
      Forward gears number 4 and 4
      Reverse gears number 4 and 4

      Backdigger

      Hinge joint radius in folded state 6604 mm and 5440 mm
      Hinge joint radius in unfolded state 7868 mm and 6530 mm

      Images

      Sizes

      1. Transport length 7954 mm 1. Transport length 7086.6 mm
      2. Transport width 2432 mm 2. Transport width 2180 mm
      3. Transport height 4193 mm 3. Transport height 3430 mm
      4. Wheelbase 2233 mm 4. Wheelbase 2110 mm
      5. Clearance 332 mm 5. Clearance 305 mm
      6. Height to cab upper part 2864 mm 6. Height to cab upper part 2743.2 mm

      Load-transfer device

      7. Ground clearance at maximum unloading height 2699 mm 7. Ground clearance at maximum unloading height 2690 mm
      8. Radius at max unloading height 868 mm 8. Radius at max unloading height 785 mm
      9. Digging depth 162 mm 9. Digging depth 160 mm

      Backdigger

      12. Digging depth in folded state 5219 mm 12. Digging depth in folded state 4340 mm
      10. Loading height in folded state 4310 mm 10. Loading height in folded state 3330 mm
      11. Hinge joint radius in folded state 6604 mm 11. Hinge joint radius in folded state 5440 mm