vs.

      Komatsu PW150ES-6 vs. Caterpillar M316C

      10 reasons to buy Komatsu PW150ES-6:

      Swing device

      Rotation speed 12 rev / min and 10.5 rev / min 12 % more or 1.5 rev

      Operation

      Front differential fluid volume 15 l. and 10.5 l. 30 % more or 4.5 l.
      Rear differential fluid volume 20 l. and 14 l. 30 % more or 6 l.

      Motor

      Power measured at 2300 rev / min and 2000 rev / min 13 % more or 300 rev

      Gear box

      Reverse gears number 3 and 2 33 % more or 1
      Forward gears number 3 and 2 33 % more or 1

      Boom/section options 4

      Maximum loading height 6605 mm and 6020 mm 9 % more or 585 mm
      Maximum vertical wall digging depth 3886 mm and 3490 mm 10 % more or 396 mm

      Boom/section options 3

      Maximum vertical wall digging depth 4445 mm and 4070 mm 8 % more or 375 mm

      Boom/section options 2

      Maximum vertical wall digging depth 3956 mm and 3900 mm 1 % more or 56 mm

      22 reasons to buy Caterpillar M316C:

      Operation

      Fuel Capacity 310 l. and 250 l. 19 % more or 60 l.
      Cooling system fluid volume 39 l. and 20 l. 49 % more or 19 l.
      Hydraulic system fluid volume 230 l. and 135 l. 41 % more or 95 l.
      Generator current strength 75 amperes and 45 amperes 40 % more or 30 amperes
      Hydraulic system overflow valve pressure 35000 kPa and 31874.4 kPa 9 % more or 3125.6 kPa
      Hydraulic pump flow rate 245 l/min and 299 l/min 18 % less or 54 l/min

      Motor

      Effective power 104.4 kW and 79.8 kW 24 % more or 24.6 kW
      Displacement 6 l. and 3.9 l. 35 % more or 2.1 l.
      Cylinders number 6 and 4 33 % more or 2

      Gear box

      Maximum travel speed 34 km/h and 30 km/h 12 % more or 4 km/h

      Boom/section options 4

      Maximum excavation depth 5370 mm and 4980 mm 7 % more or 390 mm
      Maximum radius along ground level 8710 mm and 7925 mm 9 % more or 785 mm

      Boom/section options 3

      Maximum excavation depth 6070 mm and 5620 mm 7 % more or 450 mm
      Maximum radius along ground level 9380 mm and 8560 mm 9 % more or 820 mm
      Maximum loading height 7320 mm and 6930 mm 5 % more or 390 mm

      Boom/section options 2

      Maximum excavation depth 5870 mm and 5120 mm 13 % more or 750 mm
      Maximum radius along ground level 9190 mm and 8050 mm 12 % more or 1140 mm
      Maximum loading height 7160 mm and 6560 mm 8 % more or 600 mm

      Boom/section options 1

      Maximum excavation depth 5570 mm and 4720 mm 15 % more or 850 mm
      Maximum radius along ground level 8910 mm and 7670 mm 14 % more or 1240 mm
      Maximum loading height 6970 mm and 6330 mm 9 % more or 640 mm
      Maximum vertical wall digging depth 3700 mm and 3610 mm 2 % more or 90 mm

      Neutral reasons:

      Operation

      Working weight 16490 kg and 17850 kg
      Engine oil volume 16 l. and 16 l.
      Oscillatory axle angle 14 degrees and 18 degrees

      Motor

      Aspiration turbocharging and Turbocharging with subsequent air cooling (by a cooling radiator)
      Manufacturer Komatsu and Caterpillar
      Model SA4D102E-1 and 3056E DIT ATAAC

      Gear box

      Transmission type automatic and Hydro-Static Transmission

      Boom/section options 4

      Maximum cut height 8965 mm and 9000 mm
      Option - Boom/Section (MEX) 4 two-piece boom / Section 2100mm and Boom 5050mm / Section 2100mm

      Boom/section options 3

      Maximum cut height 9270 mm and 10400 mm
      Option - Boom/Section (MEX) 3 Boom / Section 3000mm and VA Boom 5200mm / Section 2600mm

      Boom/section options 2

      Option - Boom/Section (MEX) 2 Boom / Section 2500mm and VA Boom 5200mm / Section 2400mm
      Maximum cut height 8890 mm and 10250 mm

      Boom/section options 1

      Option - Boom/Section (MEX) 1 Boom / Section 2100mm and VA Boom 5200mm / Section 2100mm
      Maximum cut height 8660 mm and 10060 mm

      Images

      Boom/section options 1

      9. Maximum cut height 8965 mm 9. Maximum cut height 10250 mm
      10. Maximum loading height 6605 mm 10. Maximum loading height 7160 mm
      11. Maximum radius along ground level 7925 mm 11. Maximum radius along ground level 9190 mm
      12. Maximum vertical wall digging depth 3886 mm 12. Maximum vertical wall digging depth 3900 mm
      13. Maximum excavation depth 4980 mm 13. Maximum excavation depth 5870 mm