- Home/
- Comparison/
- Wheeled Excavator/
- Komatsu PW150ES-6 vs. Caterpillar M316D
Komatsu PW150ES-6 vs. Caterpillar M316D
10 reasons to buy Komatsu PW150ES-6:
Swing device
Rotation speed | 12 rev / min and 10.5 rev / min | 12 % more or 1.5 rev |
Operation
Engine oil volume | 16 l. and 15 l. | 6 % more or 1 l. |
Front differential fluid volume | 15 l. and 10.5 l. | 30 % more or 4.5 l. |
Rear differential fluid volume | 20 l. and 14 l. | 30 % more or 6 l. |
Motor
Power measured at | 2300 rev / min and 1800 rev / min | 22 % more or 500 rev |
Gear box
Forward gears number | 3 and 2 | 33 % more or 1 |
Reverse gears number | 3 and 2 | 33 % more or 1 |
Boom/section options 3
Maximum loading height | 6930 mm and 6020 mm | 13 % more or 910 mm |
Maximum vertical wall digging depth | 4445 mm and 3490 mm | 21 % more or 955 mm |
Maximum excavation depth | 5620 mm and 5370 mm | 4 % more or 250 mm |
24 reasons to buy Caterpillar M316D:
Operation
Cooling system fluid volume | 32 l. and 20 l. | 37 % more or 12 l. |
Hydraulic system fluid volume | 220 l. and 135 l. | 39 % more or 85 l. |
Generator current strength | 75 amperes and 45 amperes | 40 % more or 30 amperes |
Hydraulic system overflow valve pressure | 34997.8 kPa and 31874.4 kPa | 9 % more or 3123.4 kPa |
Fuel Capacity | 310 l. and 250 l. | 19 % more or 60 l. |
Hydraulic pump flow rate | 250 l/min and 299 l/min | 16 % less or 49 l/min |
Motor
Full power | 124 kW and 83.5 kW | 33 % more or 40.5 kW |
Effective power | 118 kW and 79.8 kW | 32 % more or 38.2 kW |
Displacement | 6.6 l. and 3.9 l. | 41 % more or 2.7 l. |
Cylinders number | 6 and 4 | 33 % more or 2 |
Gear box
Maximum travel speed | 37 km/h and 30 km/h | 19 % more or 7 km/h |
Boom/section options 4
Maximum excavation depth | 5450 mm and 4980 mm | 9 % more or 470 mm |
Maximum radius along ground level | 8780 mm and 7925 mm | 10 % more or 855 mm |
Maximum loading height | 7150 mm and 6605 mm | 8 % more or 545 mm |
Maximum vertical wall digging depth | 4100 mm and 3886 mm | 5 % more or 214 mm |
Boom/section options 3
Maximum radius along ground level | 8710 mm and 8560 mm | 2 % more or 150 mm |
Boom/section options 2
Maximum excavation depth | 6070 mm and 5120 mm | 16 % more or 950 mm |
Maximum radius along ground level | 9380 mm and 8050 mm | 14 % more or 1330 mm |
Maximum loading height | 7320 mm and 6560 mm | 10 % more or 760 mm |
Maximum vertical wall digging depth | 4070 mm and 3956 mm | 3 % more or 114 mm |
Boom/section options 1
Maximum excavation depth | 5570 mm and 4720 mm | 15 % more or 850 mm |
Maximum radius along ground level | 8910 mm and 7670 mm | 14 % more or 1240 mm |
Maximum loading height | 6970 mm and 6330 mm | 9 % more or 640 mm |
Maximum vertical wall digging depth | 3700 mm and 3610 mm | 2 % more or 90 mm |
Neutral reasons:
Operation
Type of hydraulic pump | variable displacement piston pump and piston pump |
Working weight | 16490 kg and 19400 kg |
Oscillatory axle angle | 14 degrees and 9 degrees |
Motor
Model | SA4D102E-1 and C6.6 Acert |
Manufacturer | Komatsu and Caterpillar |
Gear box
Transmission type | automatic and gear |
Boom/section options 4
Option - Boom/Section (MEX) 4 | two-piece boom / Section 2100mm and Displaced boom 5.2 m / Section 2.1 m |
Maximum cut height | 8965 mm and 9960 mm |
Boom/section options 3
Option - Boom/Section (MEX) 3 | Boom / Section 3000mm and one-piece boom 5.05 m / Section 2.1 m |
Maximum cut height | 9270 mm and 9000 mm |
Boom/section options 2
Maximum cut height | 8890 mm and 10400 mm |
Option - Boom/Section (MEX) 2 | Boom / Section 2500mm and VA Boom 5.2 m / Section 2.6 m |
Boom/section options 1
Option - Boom/Section (MEX) 1 | Boom / Section 2100mm and Va Boom 5.2 m / Section 2.1 m |
Maximum cut height | 8660 mm and 10060 mm |
Images
Boom/section options 1
9. Maximum cut height | 8890 mm | 9. Maximum cut height | 9000 mm |
10. Maximum loading height | 6560 mm | 10. Maximum loading height | 6020 mm |
11. Maximum radius along ground level | 7670 mm | 11. Maximum radius along ground level | 8710 mm |
12. Maximum vertical wall digging depth | 3610 mm | 12. Maximum vertical wall digging depth | 3490 mm |
13. Maximum excavation depth | 4720 mm | 13. Maximum excavation depth | 5370 mm |