Komatsu PW210-1 vs. Caterpillar M316D

12 reasons to buy Komatsu PW210-1:

Swing device

Rotation speed

13 rev / min and 10.5 rev / min

19 % more or 2.5 rev

Sizes

Upper structure clearance

1310 mm and 1280 mm

2 % more or 30 mm

Shovel

Maximum bucket volume

1.2 m3 and 1.1 m3

8 % more or 0.1 m3

Motor

Power measured at

2100 rev / min and 1800 rev / min

14 % more or 300 rev

Boom/section options 3

Maximum loading height	6190 mm and 6020 mm	3 % more or 170 mm
Maximum vertical wall digging depth	4710 mm and 3490 mm	26 % more or 1220 mm

Boom/section options 2

Maximum radius along ground level	9600 mm and 9380 mm	2 % more or 220 mm
Maximum vertical wall digging depth	5700 mm and 4070 mm	29 % more or 1630 mm
Maximum excavation depth	6300 mm and 6070 mm	4 % more or 230 mm

Boom/section options 1

Maximum excavation depth	5800 mm and 5570 mm	4 % more or 230 mm
Maximum radius along ground level	9170 mm and 8910 mm	3 % more or 260 mm
Maximum vertical wall digging depth	5340 mm and 3700 mm	31 % more or 1640 mm

12 reasons to buy Caterpillar M316D:

Sizes

Clearance

370 mm and 335 mm

9 % more or 35 mm

Operation

Fuel Capacity	310 l. and 280 l.	10 % more or 30 l.
Hydraulic system fluid volume	220 l. and 150 l.	32 % more or 70 l.
Hydraulic system overflow valve pressure	34997.8 kPa and 34335.9 kPa	2 % more or 661.9 kPa
Hydraulic pump flow rate	250 l/min and 439 l/min	43 % less or 189 l/min

Motor

Displacement	6.6 l. and 6.5 l.	2 % more or 0.1 l.
Full power	124 kW and 114 kW	8 % more or 10 kW

Gear box

Maximum travel speed

37 km/h and 34.9 km/h

6 % more or 2.1 km/h

Boom/section options 3

Maximum excavation depth	5370 mm and 5180 mm	4 % more or 190 mm
Maximum radius along ground level	8710 mm and 8590 mm	1 % more or 120 mm

Boom/section options 2

Maximum loading height

7320 mm and 6540 mm

11 % more or 780 mm

Boom/section options 1

Maximum loading height

6970 mm and 6460 mm

7 % more or 510 mm

Neutral reasons:

Sizes

Overall width	2610 mm and 2550 mm
Height to cab upper part	3130 mm and 3170 mm
Wheelbase	2800 mm and 2600 mm
Rear platform swing radius	2700 mm and 2280 mm

Operation

Working weight

18980 kg and 19400 kg

Motor

Cylinders number	6 and 6
Manufacturer	Komatsu and Caterpillar
Model	S6D105 and C6.6 Acert

Gear box

Forward gears number	2 and 2
Reverse gears number	2 and 2

Boom/section options 3

Option - Boom/Section (MEX) 3	Boom 18'8" (5700mm)/Section 5'11" (1800mm) and one-piece boom 5.05 m / Section 2.1 m
Maximum cut height	8910 mm and 9000 mm

Boom/section options 2

Maximum cut height	9040 mm and 10400 mm
Option - Boom/Section (MEX) 2	Boom 18'8" (5700mm)/Section 9'7" (2925mm) and VA Boom 5.2 m / Section 2.6 m
Unit load-transfer height	3740 mm and 3170 mm
Unit load-transfer length	9460 mm and 8540 mm

Boom/section options 1

Maximum cut height	9200 mm and 10060 mm
Option - Boom/Section (MEX) 1	Boom 18'8" (5700mm)/Section 7'11" (2410mm) and Va Boom 5.2 m / Section 2.1 m
Unit load-transfer height	3740 mm and 3170 mm
Unit load-transfer length	9480 mm and 8550 mm

Images

Sizes

2. Overall width	2610 mm	2. Overall width	2550 mm
4. Wheelbase	2800 mm	4. Wheelbase	2600 mm
5. Clearance	335 mm	5. Clearance	370 mm
7. Height to cab upper part	3130 mm	7. Height to cab upper part	3170 mm
8. Rear platform swing radius	2700 mm	8. Rear platform swing radius	2280 mm
14. Upper structure clearance	1310 mm	14. Upper structure clearance	1280 mm

Boom/section options 1

3. Unit load-transfer height	3740 mm	3. Unit load-transfer height	3170 mm
12. Maximum vertical wall digging depth	4710 mm	12. Maximum vertical wall digging depth	3700 mm
9. Maximum cut height	9200 mm	9. Maximum cut height	10060 mm
13. Maximum excavation depth	5180 mm	13. Maximum excavation depth	5570 mm
10. Maximum loading height	6460 mm	10. Maximum loading height	6970 mm
11. Maximum radius along ground level	9170 mm	11. Maximum radius along ground level	8910 mm
1. Unit load-transfer length	9480 mm	1. Unit load-transfer length	8540 mm