- Home/
- Comparison/
- Self-Powered Scraper/
- Komatsu WS16S-2 vs. Caterpillar 631G
Komatsu WS16S-2 vs. Caterpillar 631G
1 reasons to buy Komatsu WS16S-2:
Sizes
Tractor clearance | 670 mm and 665 mm | 1 % more or 5 mm |
7 reasons to buy Caterpillar 631G:
Tractor engine
Displacement | 18 l. and 14 l. | 22 % more or 4 l. |
Full power | 384 kW and 271.4 kW | 29 % more or 112.6 kW |
Gear box
Maximum forward speed | 53.5 km/h and 52 km/h | 3 % more or 1.5 km/h |
Cup
Volume with top | 23.7 m3 and 16 m3 | 32 % more or 7.7 m3 |
Brimmed volume | 16.1 m3 and 11 m3 | 32 % more or 5.1 m3 |
Maximum cutting depth | 437 mm and 370 mm | 15 % more or 67 mm |
Cut width | 3512 mm and 3180 mm | 9 % more or 332 mm |
Neutral reasons:
Weight
Total operating unloaded | 30800 kg and 46475 kg |
Total operating loaded | 53400 kg and 80495 kg |
Tractor engine
Manufacturer | Komatsu and Caterpillar |
Model | Cummins NTA855-C and 3408E |
Sizes
Wheelbase | 2400 mm and 8769 mm |
Dimensional length | 12775 mm and 14565 mm |
Overall width | 3490 mm and 3938 mm |
Height to cab upper part | 3520 mm and 3715 mm |
Headroom | 4480 mm and 4286 mm |
Gear box
Transmission type | Torqueflow Transmission (with the flow of torque) of planetary type and 8-speed automatic power transmission with electronic control |
Forward gears number | 8 and 8 |
Reverse gears number | 1 and 1 |
Cup
Nominal payload | 22400 kg and 34020 kg |
Images
Sizes
1. Dimensional length | 12775 mm | 1. Dimensional length | 14565 mm |
2. Overall width | 3490 mm | 2. Overall width | 3938 mm |
3. Headroom | 4480 mm | 3. Headroom | 4286 mm |
4. Wheelbase | 2400 mm | 4. Wheelbase | 8769 mm |
5. Tractor clearance | 670 mm | 5. Tractor clearance | 665 mm |
6. Height to cab upper part | 3520 mm | 6. Height to cab upper part | 3715 mm |