- Home/
- Comparison/
- Self-Powered Scraper/
- Komatsu WS23S-1 vs. Caterpillar 657G
Komatsu WS23S-1 vs. Caterpillar 657G
2 reasons to buy Komatsu WS23S-1:
Tractor engine
Displacement | 18.8 l. and 18.1 l. | 4 % more or 0.7 l. |
Cup
Maximum cutting depth | 900 mm and 425 mm | 53 % more or 475 mm |
11 reasons to buy Caterpillar 657G:
Tractor engine
Full power | 471 kW and 326.6 kW | 31 % more or 144.4 kW |
Sizes
Tractor clearance | 645 mm and 510 mm | 21 % more or 135 mm |
Operation
Fuel Capacity | 1597 l. and 850 l. | 47 % more or 747 l. |
Cooling system fluid volume | 213 l. and 140 l. | 34 % more or 73 l. |
Engine oil volume | 102 l. and 72 l. | 29 % more or 30 l. |
Transmission fluid volume | 257 l. and 70 l. | 73 % more or 187 l. |
Differential fluid volume | 301 l. and 50 l. | 83 % more or 251 l. |
Gear box
Maximum forward speed | 55.7 km/h and 52 km/h | 7 % more or 3.7 km/h |
Cup
Brimmed volume | 24.5 m3 and 16 m3 | 35 % more or 8.5 m3 |
Cut width | 3846 mm and 3380 mm | 12 % more or 466 mm |
Volume with top | 33.6 m3 and 24 m3 | 29 % more or 9.6 m3 |
Neutral reasons:
Weight
Loaded front axle | 38335 kg and 58624 kg |
Loaded rear axle | 31365 kg and 56325 kg |
Total operating unloaded | 35700 kg and 67774 kg |
Front axle unloaded | 23562 kg and 40665 kg |
Rear axle unloaded | 12138 kg and 27110 kg |
Total operating loaded | 69700 kg and 114949 kg |
Tractor engine
Model | KT1150 and C18 ACERT |
Manufacturer | Cummins and Caterpillar |
Sizes
Dimensional length | 13470 mm and 16164 mm |
Overall width | 3690 mm and 4344 mm |
Height to cab upper part | 3520 mm and 3712 mm |
Headroom | 4750 mm and 4710 mm |
Wheelbase | 8390 mm and 9956 mm |
Operation
Tyre size | 33.5-33-32PR and 40.5/75 R39 |
Gear box
Transmission type | planetary gear and 8-speed automatic power transmission with electronic control |
Forward gears number | 8 and 8 |
Reverse gears number | 1 and 1 |
Cup
Nominal payload | 34000 kg and 47200 kg |
Images
Sizes
3. Headroom | 4750 mm | 3. Headroom | 4710 mm |
4. Wheelbase | 8390 mm | 4. Wheelbase | 9956 mm |
5. Tractor clearance | 510 mm | 5. Tractor clearance | 645 mm |
6. Height to cab upper part | 3520 mm | 6. Height to cab upper part | 3712 mm |
1. Dimensional length | 13470 mm | 1. Dimensional length | 16164 mm |
2. Overall width | 3690 mm | 2. Overall width | 4344 mm |