vs.

      Komatsu WA380-3 Asset+ vs. Caterpillar 910E

      21 reasons to buy Komatsu WA380-3 Asset+:

      Sizes

      Clearance 440 mm and 343.4 mm 22 % more or 96.6 mm
      Radius at maximum lifting and unloading 1112 mm and 1006 mm 10 % more or 106 mm

      Shovel

      Unloading ground clearance at maximum lifting 3010 mm and 2577 mm 14 % more or 433 mm
      Bucket capacity with top 3.1 m3 and 1 m3 68 % more or 2.1 m3

      Operation

      Fuel Capacity 287 l. and 97 l. 66 % more or 190 l.
      Hydraulic system fluid volume 190 l. and 70 l. 63 % more or 120 l.
      Engine oil volume 22.4 l. and 11 l. 51 % more or 11.4 l.
      Cooling system fluid volume 53 l. and 30 l. 43 % more or 23 l.
      Transmission fluid volume 48 l. and 23 l. 52 % more or 25 l.
      Front axle / differential fluid volume 37 l. and 18 l. 51 % more or 19 l.
      Rear axle / differential fluid volume 37 l. and 18 l. 51 % more or 19 l.
      Static tipping weight 14125 kg and 4759 kg 66 % more or 9366 kg

      Motor

      Displacement 8.3 l. and 4.4 l. 47 % more or 3.9 l.
      Cylinders number 6 and 4 33 % more or 2
      Full power 143.2 kW and 60.4 kW 58 % more or 82.8 kW

      Hydraulic system

      Pump bandwidth 300 l/min and 112 l/min 63 % more or 188 l/min
      Lifting time 5.1 sec and 5.3 sec 4 % less or 0.2 sec
      Lowering time 3 sec and 3.2 sec 6 % less or 0.2 sec

      Gear box

      Reverse gears number 4 and 3 25 % more or 1
      Maximum forward speed 37 km/h and 36 km/h 3 % more or 1 km/h
      Maximum reverse gear 38 km/h and 24 km/h 37 % more or 14 km/h

      5 reasons to buy Caterpillar 910E:

      Shovel

      Breakout power 74 kN and 155 kN 52 % less or 81 kN

      Operation

      Turn radius 4811.5 mm and 5840 mm 18 % less or 1028.5 mm
      Generator current strength 55 amperes and 50 amperes 9 % more or 5 amperes

      Motor

      Power measured at 2400 rev / min and 2200 rev / min 8 % more or 200 rev

      Hydraulic system

      Unloading time 1.3 sec and 1.5 sec 13 % less or 0.2 sec

      Neutral reasons:

      Sizes

      Height to cab upper part 3380 mm and 2996 mm
      Length with bucket on ground level 7845 mm and 5970 mm
      Between tyres width 2770 mm and 2150 mm
      Wheelbase 3200 mm and 2337 mm
      Hinge axis maximum height 4077 mm and 3350 mm

      Shovel

      Shovel width 2916 mm and 2320 mm

      Operation

      Rear axle oscillating 30 degrees and 22 degrees
      Tyre size 23.5 R 25 XHA L3 and 15.5x25 8 PR(L-2)
      Working weight 17670 kg and 7248 kg
      Operating voltage 24 V and 24 V

      Motor

      Aspiration turbocharging and turbocharging
      Manufacturer Komatsu and Caterpillar
      Model S6D114 E-1 and 3114

      Hydraulic system

      Overflow valve pressure 21000 kPa and 15196 kPa

      Gear box

      Transmission type fully automatic powershift and powershift
      Forward gears number 4 and 4

      Images

      Sizes

      1. Length with bucket on ground level 7845 mm 1. Length with bucket on ground level 5970 mm
      2. Between tyres width 2770 mm 2. Between tyres width 2150 mm
      3. Height to cab upper part 3380 mm 3. Height to cab upper part 2996 mm
      4. Wheelbase 3200 mm 4. Wheelbase 2337 mm
      5. Clearance 440 mm 5. Clearance 343.4 mm
      6. Hinge axis maximum height 4077 mm 6. Hinge axis maximum height 3350 mm
      8. Radius at maximum lifting and unloading 1112 mm 8. Radius at maximum lifting and unloading 1006 mm

      Shovel

      7. Unloading ground clearance at maximum lifting 3010 mm 7. Unloading ground clearance at maximum lifting 2577 mm