- Home/
- Comparison/
- Wheel-Mounted Loader/
- Komatsu WA380-3 Asset+ vs. Caterpillar 910E
Komatsu WA380-3 Asset+ vs. Caterpillar 910E
21 reasons to buy Komatsu WA380-3 Asset+:
Sizes
Clearance | 440 mm and 343.4 mm | 22 % more or 96.6 mm |
Radius at maximum lifting and unloading | 1112 mm and 1006 mm | 10 % more or 106 mm |
Shovel
Unloading ground clearance at maximum lifting | 3010 mm and 2577 mm | 14 % more or 433 mm |
Bucket capacity with top | 3.1 m3 and 1 m3 | 68 % more or 2.1 m3 |
Operation
Fuel Capacity | 287 l. and 97 l. | 66 % more or 190 l. |
Hydraulic system fluid volume | 190 l. and 70 l. | 63 % more or 120 l. |
Engine oil volume | 22.4 l. and 11 l. | 51 % more or 11.4 l. |
Cooling system fluid volume | 53 l. and 30 l. | 43 % more or 23 l. |
Transmission fluid volume | 48 l. and 23 l. | 52 % more or 25 l. |
Front axle / differential fluid volume | 37 l. and 18 l. | 51 % more or 19 l. |
Rear axle / differential fluid volume | 37 l. and 18 l. | 51 % more or 19 l. |
Static tipping weight | 14125 kg and 4759 kg | 66 % more or 9366 kg |
Motor
Displacement | 8.3 l. and 4.4 l. | 47 % more or 3.9 l. |
Cylinders number | 6 and 4 | 33 % more or 2 |
Full power | 143.2 kW and 60.4 kW | 58 % more or 82.8 kW |
Hydraulic system
Pump bandwidth | 300 l/min and 112 l/min | 63 % more or 188 l/min |
Lifting time | 5.1 sec and 5.3 sec | 4 % less or 0.2 sec |
Lowering time | 3 sec and 3.2 sec | 6 % less or 0.2 sec |
Gear box
Reverse gears number | 4 and 3 | 25 % more or 1 |
Maximum forward speed | 37 km/h and 36 km/h | 3 % more or 1 km/h |
Maximum reverse gear | 38 km/h and 24 km/h | 37 % more or 14 km/h |
5 reasons to buy Caterpillar 910E:
Shovel
Breakout power | 74 kN and 155 kN | 52 % less or 81 kN |
Operation
Turn radius | 4811.5 mm and 5840 mm | 18 % less or 1028.5 mm |
Generator current strength | 55 amperes and 50 amperes | 9 % more or 5 amperes |
Motor
Power measured at | 2400 rev / min and 2200 rev / min | 8 % more or 200 rev |
Hydraulic system
Unloading time | 1.3 sec and 1.5 sec | 13 % less or 0.2 sec |
Neutral reasons:
Sizes
Height to cab upper part | 3380 mm and 2996 mm |
Length with bucket on ground level | 7845 mm and 5970 mm |
Between tyres width | 2770 mm and 2150 mm |
Wheelbase | 3200 mm and 2337 mm |
Hinge axis maximum height | 4077 mm and 3350 mm |
Shovel
Shovel width | 2916 mm and 2320 mm |
Operation
Rear axle oscillating | 30 degrees and 22 degrees |
Tyre size | 23.5 R 25 XHA L3 and 15.5x25 8 PR(L-2) |
Working weight | 17670 kg and 7248 kg |
Operating voltage | 24 V and 24 V |
Motor
Aspiration | turbocharging and turbocharging |
Manufacturer | Komatsu and Caterpillar |
Model | S6D114 E-1 and 3114 |
Hydraulic system
Overflow valve pressure | 21000 kPa and 15196 kPa |
Gear box
Transmission type | fully automatic powershift and powershift |
Forward gears number | 4 and 4 |
Images
Sizes
1. Length with bucket on ground level | 7845 mm | 1. Length with bucket on ground level | 5970 mm |
2. Between tyres width | 2770 mm | 2. Between tyres width | 2150 mm |
3. Height to cab upper part | 3380 mm | 3. Height to cab upper part | 2996 mm |
4. Wheelbase | 3200 mm | 4. Wheelbase | 2337 mm |
5. Clearance | 440 mm | 5. Clearance | 343.4 mm |
6. Hinge axis maximum height | 4077 mm | 6. Hinge axis maximum height | 3350 mm |
8. Radius at maximum lifting and unloading | 1112 mm | 8. Radius at maximum lifting and unloading | 1006 mm |
Shovel
7. Unloading ground clearance at maximum lifting | 3010 mm | 7. Unloading ground clearance at maximum lifting | 2577 mm |