- Home/
- Comparison/
- All Terrain Crane/
- Tadano GR150XL-1 vs. Broderson IC200-3F
Tadano GR150XL-1 vs. Broderson IC200-3F
12 reasons to buy Tadano GR150XL-1:
Sizes
Upperstructure rear swing radius | 1600 mm and 1828.8 mm | 13 % less or 228.8 mm |
Operation
Fuel Capacity | 189 l. and 113.6 l. | 40 % more or 75.4 l. |
Motor
Maximum torque | 480 Nm and 329.5 Nm | 31 % more or 150.5 Nm |
Full power | 100.7 kW and 82 kW | 19 % more or 18.7 kW |
Gear box
Forward gears number | 6 and 4 | 33 % more or 2 |
Maximum forward speed | 49 km/h and 32.2 km/h | 34 % more or 16.8 km/h |
Booms
Rotation speed | 2.4 rev / min and 1.8 rev / min | 25 % more or 0.6 rev |
Minimum operating radius | 1.2 m and 1.8 m | 33 % less or 0.6 m |
Sections number | 6 and 4 | 33 % more or 2 |
Minimum height at maximum lifting angle | 7.6 m and 7.8 m | 3 % less or 0.2 m |
Max. height at max. lifting angle without boom | 25.9 m and 17.9 m | 31 % more or 8.0 m |
Maximum angle of ascent | 82 degrees and 73 degrees | 11 % more or 9 degrees |
6 reasons to buy Broderson IC200-3F:
Sizes
Clearance | 347.5 mm and 257 mm | 26 % more or 90.5 mm |
Operation
Hydraulic system fluid volume | 204.4 l. and 172 l. | 16 % more or 32.4 l. |
Motor
Displacement | 4.3 l. and 3.9 l. | 9 % more or 0.4 l. |
Gear box
Reverse gears number | 4 and 2 | 50 % more or 2 |
Booms
Maximum lifting capacity | 13680.3 kg and 13607.8 kg | 1 % more or 72.5 kg |
Maximum working radius | 20.1 m and 21.3 m | 6 % less or 1.2 m |
Neutral reasons:
Sizes
Transport length | 7430 mm and 6925.1 mm |
Transport width | 2000 mm and 2438.4 mm |
Transport height | 2800 mm and 2420.1 mm |
Wheelbase | 2750 mm and 2462.8 mm |
Width with extended supports | 4700 mm and 3633.2 mm |
Chassis/base length | 5740 mm and 4547.6 mm |
Operation
Working weight | 12341.3 kg and 13680.3 kg |
Tyre size | 275/80R22.5 and 15x22.5 |
Motor
Model | QSB3.9-30TAA and GM 4.3L V-6 |
Gear box
Transmission type | fully automatic powershift and powershift |
Images
Sizes
2. Transport width | 2000 mm | 2. Transport width | 2438.4 mm |
3. Transport height | 2800 mm | 3. Transport height | 2420.1 mm |
4. Wheelbase | 2750 mm | 4. Wheelbase | 2462.8 mm |
5. Clearance | 257 mm | 5. Clearance | 347.5 mm |
6. Width with extended supports | 4700 mm | 6. Width with extended supports | 3633.2 mm |
7. Chassis/base length | 5740 mm | 7. Chassis/base length | 4547.6 mm |
8. Upperstructure rear swing radius | 1600 mm | 8. Upperstructure rear swing radius | 1828.8 mm |
1. Transport length | 7430 mm | 1. Transport length | 6925.1 mm |
Booms
9. Minimum height at maximum lifting angle | 7.6 m | 9. Minimum height at maximum lifting angle | 7.8 m |
10. Max. height at max. lifting angle without boom | 25.9 m | 10. Max. height at max. lifting angle without boom | 17.9 m |
11. Minimum operating radius | 1.2 m | 11. Minimum operating radius | 1.8 m |
12. Maximum working radius | 21.3 m | 12. Maximum working radius | 20.1 m |
13. Maximum angle of ascent | 82 degrees | 13. Maximum angle of ascent | 73 degrees |