vs.

      Tadano ATF-650XL-2 vs. Grove GMK5210

      6 reasons to buy Tadano ATF-650XL-2:

      Upper-stage engine

      Power measured at 2300 rev / min and 2000 rev / min 13 % more or 300 rev

      Sizes

      Upperstructure rear swing radius 3450.3 mm and 4995 mm 31 % less or 1544.7 mm

      Gear box

      Forward gears number 12 and 5 58 % more or 7
      Reverse gears number 2 and 1 50 % more or 1

      Booms

      Minimum height at maximum lifting angle 10.4 m and 13.4 m 22 % less or 3.0 m
      Rotation speed 2 rev / min and 1.7 rev / min 15 % more or 0.3 rev

      14 reasons to buy Grove GMK5210:

      Upper-stage engine

      Full power 123 kW and 90 kW 27 % more or 33 kW

      Operation

      Axels number 5 and 4 20 % more or 1
      Upper structure fuel volume 200 l. and 199.9 l. 0 % more or 0.1 l.
      Haul truck fuel volume 400 l. and 299 l. 25 % more or 101 l.
      Generator current strength 100 amperes and 80 amperes 20 % more or 20 amperes

      Gear box

      Maximum forward speed 82 km/h and 80 km/h 2 % more or 2 km/h

      Carrying part engine

      Full power 448 kW and 260.2 kW 42 % more or 187.8 kW
      Power measured at 2000 rev / min and 1800 rev / min 10 % more or 200 rev
      Maximum torque 2780 Nm and 1730 Nm 38 % more or 1050 Nm
      Torque measured at 1400 rev / min and 1080 rev / min 23 % more or 320 rev

      Booms

      Sections number 6 and 5 17 % more or 1
      Max. height at max. lifting angle without boom 60 m and 40.2 m 33 % more or 19.8 m
      Maximum lifting capacity 190508.8 kg and 58967 kg 69 % more or 131541.8 kg
      Maximum working radius 54.9 m and 36.6 m 33 % more or 18.3 m

      Neutral reasons:

      Upper-stage engine

      Manufacturer Mercedes-Benz and Cummins
      Model OM 904 LA and 6BTA 5.9-C

      Sizes

      Transport length 11780 mm and 15630 mm
      Transport width 2820 mm and 3070 mm
      Transport height 3650 mm and 3956 mm
      Width with extended supports 6270 mm and 8300 mm
      Hauler length 9986 mm and 13560 mm

      Operation

      Working weight 53750.7 kg and 61026.3 kg
      Operating voltage 24 V and 24 V
      Tyre size 20.5R25 and 20.5R25

      Gear box

      Transmission type ZF AS-Tronic 12AS2301 mechanical transmission and Allison automatic CLT 755

      Carrying part engine

      Model OM 501 LA and Signature 600
      Manufacturer Mercedes-Benz and Cummins

      Booms

      Maximum angle of ascent 82 degrees and 82 degrees
      Minimum operating radius 2.7 m and 2.7 m

      Images

      Sizes

      8. Upperstructure rear swing radius 3450.3 mm 8. Upperstructure rear swing radius 4995 mm
      1. Transport length 11780 mm 1. Transport length 15630 mm
      2. Transport width 2820 mm 2. Transport width 3070 mm
      3. Transport height 3650 mm 3. Transport height 3956 mm
      6. Width with extended supports 6270 mm 6. Width with extended supports 8300 mm
      7. Hauler length 9986 mm 7. Hauler length 13560 mm

      Booms

      9. Minimum height at maximum lifting angle 10.4 m 9. Minimum height at maximum lifting angle 13.4 m
      10. Max. height at max. lifting angle without boom 40.2 m 10. Max. height at max. lifting angle without boom 60 m
      11. Minimum operating radius 2.7 m 11. Minimum operating radius 2.7 m
      12. Maximum working radius 36.6 m 12. Maximum working radius 54.9 m
      13. Maximum angle of ascent 82 degrees 13. Maximum angle of ascent 82 degrees