- Home/
- Comparison/
- Skidding Tractor (Skidder)/
- John Deere 648E vs. Caterpillar 515
John Deere 648E vs. Caterpillar 515
8 reasons to buy John Deere 648E:
Sizes
Clearance | 514 mm and 457 mm | 11 % more or 57 mm |
Maximum line speed | 73.8 m/min and 45.5 m/min | 38 % more or 28.3 m/min |
Operation
Generator current strength | 95 amperes and 75 amperes | 21 % more or 20 amperes |
Fuel Capacity | 197 l. and 185 l. | 6 % more or 12 l. |
Motor
Cylinders number | 6 and 4 | 33 % more or 2 |
Hydraulic system
Pump flow rate | 162.8 l/min and 172.2 l/min | 5 % less or 9.4 l/min |
Gear box
Forward gears number | 8 and 4 | 50 % more or 4 |
Reverse gears number | 4 and 3 | 25 % more or 1 |
14 reasons to buy Caterpillar 515:
Sizes
Grapple radius on ground level | 2140 mm and 1550 mm | 28 % more or 590 mm |
Drum capacity at cable width | 122 m and 54.6 m | 55 % more or 67.4 m |
Maximum traction force on a rope with empty drum | 305.9 kN and 173 kN | 43 % more or 132.9 kN |
Operation
Rear differential fluid volume | 42 l. and 28.4 l. | 32 % more or 13.6 l. |
Front differential fluid volume | 42 l. and 17 l. | 60 % more or 25 l. |
Transmission fluid volume | 53 l. and 29.3 l. | 45 % more or 23.7 l. |
Hydraulic system fluid volume | 75 l. and 41.6 l. | 45 % more or 33.4 l. |
Cooling system fluid volume | 36 l. and 24.6 l. | 32 % more or 11.4 l. |
Engine oil volume | 19 l. and 18.9 l. | 1 % more or 0.1 l. |
Motor
Full power | 113.3 kW and 110 kW | 3 % more or 3.3 kW |
Effective power | 104.4 kW and 104 kW | 0 % more or 0.4 kW |
Displacement | 7 l. and 6.8 l. | 3 % more or 0.2 l. |
Gear box
Maximum forward speed | 27.2 km/h and 26.3 km/h | 3 % more or 0.9 km/h |
Maximum reverse gear | 19.2 km/h and 9.4 km/h | 51 % more or 9.8 km/h |
Neutral reasons:
Sizes
Height to cab upper part | 3020 mm and 3030 mm |
Wheelbase | 3430 mm and 3300 mm |
Tong opening at tips | 2870 mm and 2130 mm |
Dimensional length | 7350 mm and 5800 mm |
Roller diameter | 203.2 mm and 254 mm |
Overall width | 3110 mm and 2724 mm |
Operation
Operating voltage | 12 V and 24 V |
Tyre size | 28L-26 and 23.1-26 |
Working weight | 13200 kg and 12700 kg |
Motor
Manufacturer | John Deere and Caterpillar |
Power measured at | 2200 rev / min and 2200 rev / min |
Model | 6068T and 3304 DIT |
Aspiration | turbocharging and turbocharging |
Hydraulic system
Type of pump | axial piston, with pressure compensation and Piston |
Overflow valve pressure | 20684 kPa and 20684.3 kPa |
Images
Sizes
1. Dimensional length | 7350 mm | 1. Dimensional length | 5800 mm |
2. Overall width | 3110 mm | 2. Overall width | 2724 mm |
3. Height to cab upper part | 3020 mm | 3. Height to cab upper part | 3030 mm |
4. Wheelbase | 3430 mm | 4. Wheelbase | 3300 mm |
5. Clearance | 514 mm | 5. Clearance | 457 mm |
8. Grapple radius on ground level | 1550 mm | 8. Grapple radius on ground level | 2140 mm |
9. Tong opening at tips | 2870 mm | 9. Tong opening at tips | 2130 mm |