vs.

      Caterpillar 170 vs. Komatsu HD605-5

      8 reasons to buy Caterpillar 170:

      Weight

      Loaded front weight distribution 33.3 % and 32 % 4 % more or 1.3 %
      Unloaded front weight distribution 47 % and 45 % 4 % more or 2 %

      Operation

      Fuel Capacity 3218 l. and 780 l. 76 % more or 2438 l.

      Motor

      Full power 1081.3 kW and 551.1 kW 49 % more or 530.2 kW
      Effective power 1005.2 kW and 533.2 kW 47 % more or 472.0 kW
      Displacement 51.8 l. and 23.2 l. 55 % more or 28.6 l.

      Dump

      Brimmed lifting capacity 56.9 m3 and 29 m3 49 % more or 27.9 m3
      Lifting capacity with top 78.2 m3 and 40 m3 49 % more or 38.2 m3

      3 reasons to buy Komatsu HD605-5:

      Weight

      Loaded rear weight distribution 68 % and 66.7 % 2 % more or 1.3 %
      Unloaded rear weight distribution 55 % and 53 % 4 % more or 2 %

      Gear box

      Maximum speed 70 km/h and 54 km/h 23 % more or 16 km/h

      Neutral reasons:

      Weight

      Weight without load 249480 kg and 47825 kg
      Laden weight 153760 kg and 108075 kg

      Operation

      Tyre size 33R51 and 24.00R35

      Motor

      Manufacturer BT and Komatsu
      Model 3512A and SAA6D170E

      Images