vs.

      Tata Hitachi ZAXIS650LC vs. Caterpillar 231D LC

      13 reasons to buy Tata Hitachi ZAXIS650LC:

      Sizes

      Counterweight ground clearance 1530 mm and 1250 mm 18 % more or 280 mm
      Width to outside of caterpillar track 3950 mm and 3450 mm 13 % more or 500 mm
      Clearance 860 mm and 580 mm 33 % more or 280 mm

      Operation

      Hydraulic system overflow valve pressure 34300 kPa and 33094.8 kPa 4 % more or 1205.2 kPa
      Fuel Capacity 900 l. and 400 l. 56 % more or 500 l.

      Motor

      Displacement 15.7 l. and 10.4 l. 34 % more or 5.3 l.

      Booms/sections features 2

      Maximum excavation depth 8530 mm and 7540 mm 12 % more or 990 mm
      Maximum radius along ground level 13000 mm and 11200 mm 14 % more or 1800 mm
      Maximum loading height 8050 mm and 7400 mm 8 % more or 650 mm
      Maximum vertical wall digging depth 7380 mm and 6130 mm 17 % more or 1250 mm

      Booms/sections features 1

      Maximum loading height 7330 mm and 7160 mm 2 % more or 170 mm
      Maximum excavation depth 7120 mm and 6940 mm 3 % more or 180 mm
      Maximum radius along ground level 11500 mm and 10640 mm 7 % more or 860 mm

      4 reasons to buy Caterpillar 231D LC:

      Operation

      Hydraulic pump flow rate 458 l/min and 912 l/min 50 % less or 454 l/min

      Carrier

      Specific ground pressure 46.9 kPa and 99 kPa 53 % less or 52.1 kPa
      Maximum travel speed 5.5 km/h and 4.9 km/h 11 % more or 0.6 km/h

      Booms/sections features 1

      Maximum vertical wall digging depth 5290 mm and 5280 mm 0 % more or 10 mm

      Neutral reasons:

      Sizes

      Rear platform swing radius 3850 mm and 3000 mm
      Height to cab upper part 3450 mm and 3380 mm

      Operation

      Working weight 65900 kg and 35500 kg

      Motor

      Manufacturer Isuzu and Caterpillar
      Model AH-6WG1XYSA-02 and 3208

      Carrier

      Track width 3300 mm and 2640 mm
      Shoe dimensions 650 mm and 813 mm

      Booms/sections features 2

      Maximum cut height 11920 mm and 10350 mm

      Booms/sections features 1

      Maximum cut height 11190 mm and 10080 mm

      Images

      Sizes

      7. Height to cab upper part 3450 mm 7. Height to cab upper part 3380 mm
      8. Rear platform swing radius 3850 mm 8. Rear platform swing radius 3000 mm
      15. Counterweight ground clearance 1530 mm 15. Counterweight ground clearance 1250 mm
      2. Width to outside of caterpillar track 3950 mm 2. Width to outside of caterpillar track 3450 mm
      5. Clearance 860 mm 5. Clearance 580 mm

      Carrier

      6. Track width 3300 mm 6. Track width 2640 mm
      14. Shoe dimensions 650 mm 14. Shoe dimensions 813 mm

      Booms/sections features 1

      13. Maximum excavation depth 9150 mm 13. Maximum excavation depth 7540 mm
      9. Maximum cut height 12240 mm 9. Maximum cut height 10080 mm
      10. Maximum loading height 8330 mm 10. Maximum loading height 7160 mm
      11. Maximum radius along ground level 13610 mm 11. Maximum radius along ground level 10640 mm
      12. Maximum vertical wall digging depth 8180 mm 12. Maximum vertical wall digging depth 5290 mm