vs.

      Caterpillar R1600G vs. Case 521DXT

      16 reasons to buy Caterpillar R1600G:

      Sizes

      Radius at maximum lifting and unloading 1408 mm and 1122 mm 20 % more or 286 mm

      Shovel

      Bucket capacity with top 4.8 m3 and 1.5 m3 69 % more or 3.3 m3

      Operation

      Static tipping weight 28100 kg and 8357 kg 70 % more or 19743 kg
      Fuel Capacity 400 l. and 189 l. 53 % more or 211 l.
      Hydraulic system fluid volume 125 l. and 113.6 l. 9 % more or 11.4 l.
      Engine oil volume 36.1 l. and 12.5 l. 65 % more or 23.6 l.
      Cooling system fluid volume 53 l. and 22 l. 58 % more or 31 l.
      Transmission fluid volume 47 l. and 18.9 l. 60 % more or 28.1 l.
      Front axle / differential fluid volume 80 l. and 22 l. 72 % more or 58 l.
      Rear axle / differential fluid volume 80 l. and 22 l. 72 % more or 58 l.

      Motor

      Full power 185 kW and 89 kW 52 % more or 96 kW
      Power measured at 2100 rev / min and 2000 rev / min 5 % more or 100 rev
      Displacement 10.3 l. and 4.5 l. 56 % more or 5.8 l.
      Effective power 165 kW and 82 kW 50 % more or 83 kW

      Hydraulic system

      Lowering time 2 sec and 3.7 sec 46 % less or 1.7 sec

      Gear box

      Reverse gears number 4 and 3 25 % more or 1

      8 reasons to buy Case 521DXT:

      Sizes

      Clearance 377 mm and 344 mm 9 % more or 33 mm

      Shovel

      Breakout power 21929 pound and 42505 pound 48 % less or 20576 pound
      Unloading ground clearance at maximum lifting 2757 mm and 2207 mm 20 % more or 550 mm

      Operation

      Turn radius 4947 mm and 6638 mm 25 % less or 1691 mm

      Hydraulic system

      Lifting time 5.6 sec and 7.6 sec 26 % less or 2.0 sec
      Unloading time 1.1 sec and 1.6 sec 31 % less or 0.5 sec

      Gear box

      Maximum forward speed 37.6 km/h and 22.1 km/h 41 % more or 15.5 km/h
      Maximum reverse gear 24.5 km/h and 23.8 km/h 3 % more or 0.7 km/h

      Neutral reasons:

      Sizes

      Length with bucket on ground level 10107 mm and 6715 mm
      Height to cab upper part 2400 mm and 3173 mm
      Between tyres width 2400 mm and 2308 mm
      Wheelbase 3536 mm and 2750 mm
      Hinge axis maximum height 3752 mm and 3739 mm

      Shovel

      Shovel width 2600 mm and 2468 mm

      Operation

      Working weight 29800 kg and 10858.1 kg
      Rear axle oscillating 20 degrees and 24 degrees
      Tyre size 18.00x25-28 layers and 17.5x25

      Motor

      Manufacturer Caterpillar and Case
      Model 3176C EUI ATAAC and Family III 445TA/M2, 2 level

      Gear box

      Forward gears number 4 and 4

      Images

      Sizes

      6. Hinge axis maximum height 3752 mm 6. Hinge axis maximum height 3739 mm
      8. Radius at maximum lifting and unloading 1408 mm 8. Radius at maximum lifting and unloading 1122 mm
      1. Length with bucket on ground level 10107 mm 1. Length with bucket on ground level 6715 mm
      2. Between tyres width 2400 mm 2. Between tyres width 2308 mm
      3. Height to cab upper part 2400 mm 3. Height to cab upper part 3173 mm
      4. Wheelbase 3536 mm 4. Wheelbase 2750 mm
      5. Clearance 344 mm 5. Clearance 377 mm

      Shovel

      7. Unloading ground clearance at maximum lifting 2207 mm 7. Unloading ground clearance at maximum lifting 2757 mm